7 Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies (2018 Reviews)


Without any doubt, there is no responsibility in life as huge as parenting. Sometimes you just don’t know how to deal with a crying baby during an important business discussion, and wish your baby could understand your situation and just stop crying, but unfortunately, babies only understand when their demands are met. Therefore, to provide a solution to a problem faced daily by breastfeeding moms, different kinds of pacifiers have been made, and here, we will be reviewing the best pacifiers for breastfed babies.

A pacifier is definitely a must-have for breastfeeding moms. Usually made of plastic or rubber, a pacifier is a mechanism designed to impersonate a nipple, and was made to pacify babies. Babies usually have sucking urges, therefore, a pacifier is designed to calm them down by providing them with a comforting experience similar to the one they get when they latch onto a nipple. It can be quite tough to breastfeed your baby at all times, and a pacifier is made to step in for you at times when your baby isn’t really hungry but just wants to suck your breast.

However, breastfed babies don’t feel comfortable with some pacifiers sometimes, hence they refuse to suck on them. Therefore, parents are always searching for the best pacifiers that would give their babies the sort of experience they get from sucking real nipples. Consequently, we have scoured and combed the web and we have come up with the best pacifiers for breastfed babies. In addition, we will as well be discussing the vital things you must check before purchasing the right pacifier for your new baby.

Reviews of the Best 7 Pacifiers on the Market

While all pacifiers are made to comfort babies and provide them with a soothing experience, not all of them do this job efficiently. Therefore, we have reviewed some of the best newborn pacifiers on the market, so that you can make an informed buying decision.

[amazon table=”23341″]

1. MAM Air Orthodontic Pacifier

[amazon box=”B00DYOQMC4″ template=”vertical”]

MAM is probably the biggest producer of pacifiers and that fact is further highlighted with the excellence of this baby pacifier. This nipple of this pacifier is made of silicone, therefore it has a smooth and silky feel, which feels like a real nipple. The nipple has a symmetrical design, like every great pacifier for nursing babies. However, MAM employed the services of orthodontists in the making of this pacifier to ensure any hindrance to the development of the baby’s jaw is prevented.

In addition, the shield of the pacifier is adequately large but not excessively, which enables the baby to breathe properly, and also prevent saliva accumulation. Surprisingly, several pacifiers fail to take this into consideration, so it is impressive to see this in the design of this pacifier from MAM. MAM offers 2 age options: from birth to six months and six months and above.

Furthermore, this pacifier has a straightforward and beautify design. The designs and colors are very attractive, but not extremely or overwhelmingly bright. Both the regular Air and Mini-Air pacifiers come in varieties of colors depending on gender and age of the baby.


  • Small and lightweight
  • Comes with a sterilizing case.
  • Very soft nipple
  • Beautiful design


  • Water gets stuck inside

2. Philips Avent SCF190/01 Soothie

[amazon box=”B0045I6IAO” template=”vertical”]

If you are in search of the best pacifier for your new born baby, then you should search no more as Soothie is one of the best pacifiers for breastfeeding mommies. According to customer reviews, this ground-breaking round shaped model is probably the most popular pacifier for new born babies. It was designed in such a way that it would fit the mouth of a new born baby without any hindrance to the development of the baby’s jaw.

Made of silicone material, this pacifier is often seen in hospitals as it doesn’t have any weird flavour or odor, making it a perfect match for new breastfed babies without any rejection. Besides, it is sterilizer and dishwasher safe and you need not to worry about trapped moisture or bacteria because it is a very durable and solid piece. Also, the Philips Avent Soothie adheres to guidelines, thus, a snap-on cap is included in the packaging, for sterile storage.

Usually, the first baby pacifier encountered by babies is the Philips Avent Soothie due to the fact that it is the most used pacifier in major hospitals across the world. With its vibrant color options and large shield, it is easy to find or locate this pacifier at night, which makes it a favorite for many moms and babies.

Most parents found this pacifier to be extremely easy to clean since it does not have parts that get detached. However, despite the fact that many parents are very satisfied with how this pacifier calms and soothes their babies, there are still some parents that found it a bit too big and large for newborns.


  • Orthodontic shape
  • Used in many hospitals
  • One piece build
  • Easy to sterilize.
  • Easy to clean


  • Does not work with pacifier clips.

3. The First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifier

[amazon box=”B004GY8A58″ template=”vertical”]

Made for babies of three month old at least, the First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifier is another excellent pacifier on our list, which is why it is taking the third position. Made of silicone, it is very easy to clean and sterilize this pacifier, which ensures your baby is safe from any choking danger. Also, this pacifier is very durable, comfortable, and latex-free, and you won’t face any issue of contamination provided it is cleaned regularly. To top it off, this pacifier also comes at a very affordable price.

Furthermore, to further illustrate why this pacifier is one of the best option for newborn babies, it is recommended by a lot of big hospitals all over the world as a very safe option for babies. Your baby can handle it easily and its gumdrop design enables you to affix it to some other pacifiers. Several breastfeeding moms enjoy utilizing this pacifier since it doesn’t cause any problem with often caused by other pacifiers, making it one of the best options for breastfed babies.

Although, some parents have complained a bit about the very little size of the pacifier, but they however like the cut out for the nose of their little baby. This pacifier is very easy to clean and sterilize and it is an outstanding option if you are looking for a pacifier to help your baby sleep at night and pacify her when she’s twitchy.


  • Used in many hospitals worldwide
  • Great shield
  • Excellent stability
  • Incredible sucking motion


  • They are somewhat sticky.

4. Nuby Soft Flex Pacifiers

[amazon box=”B01J88ARXE” template=”vertical”]

With a special, orthopaedic design, the Soft Flex Pacifiers from Nuby allow a baby to suck naturally as it is similar to a real nipple’s motion when breastfeeding.  Also, it comes with teething nubs, made to massage and stimulate the gum of your baby so as to remove any discomfort or pain when they are growing teeth, which makes it one of the best pacifier for nursing babies.

Furthermore, this special pacifier from Nuby is the ideal option for new born babies to the age of six months. It comes with a unique ventilation system which helps to prevent skin irritation when your baby sucks on it for an extended period of time. Most breastfeeding mothers love the design of this pacifier and it has a natural sucking motion which is similar to the nipple, which makes it one of the best choices for breastfed babies.

Most moms enjoy this pacifier because of its orthodontic design which prevents little ones from spitting it out as easily as other options. Breastfeeding mothers enjoy the nipple bumps and shape that feel great against the teeth of a baby while other mothers appreciate the fact that this pacifier comes with a carrying case and a convenient clip. However, most mothers think this is one of the best pacifiers on the market.


  • Has an orthodontic design
  • Comes with a carrying case and clip
  • Nipple feel and bums
  • Great shield


  • Too large for some babies

5. Tommee Tippee Closer To Nature Everyday Pacifier

[amazon box=”B00R7Q3GM4″ template=”vertical”]

Widely known as a terrific manufacturer of bottles for newborns, Tommee Tippee produces excellent pacifiers as well. This pacifier from the company is capable of calming a crying baby and it helps babies to adjust slowly to bottle feeding. It has an orthodontic shape which looks like the shape of the real nipple, and the pacifier is free of flavour and odors, which makes it one of the best baby pacifiers on the market.

Furthermore, the pacifier is dishwasher safe and can be easily cleaned, added to the fact that it is silicone and BPA free. The pacifier features a large shield and provides great ventilation which means your baby won’t choke from the accumulation of moisture. Its nipple is a bit larger than several other pacifiers with orthodontic design, it is perfect for babies with no teeth.

However, keep in mind that this pacifier is very smooth, therefore it may slip out of the mouth of your baby at times. If you want to drain the trapped water in the nipple, all you need to do is to squeeze the nipple.


  • BPA free
  • An orthodontic design
  • Features an adjustable pacifier nipple
  • Easy to clean


  • Water get trapped easily
  • It easily slips out of babies’ mouths

6. MAM Glow in The Dark Night Orthodontic Pacifier

[amazon box=”B0082I1IA8″ template=”vertical”]

Made by one of the biggest developmental psychologists and paediatric dentists in the world, the MAM Glow in The Dark Night Orthodontic Pacifier is one of the best options for babies within the age of 0-6 months. Because of its orthodontic design, this pacifier has a symmetrical shape that is perfect for the development of your baby’s teeth and jaw. The nipple of the pacifier is made from silicone, which has a silky feel that mimics that of real nipples so babies accept and love it easily.

Besides the fact that this pacifier glows in the dark, a feature that makes finding it at might easy, we also like the anti-slip texture of this pacifier as it ensures the nipple comfortably stays in your baby’s mouth. Alongside the rounded shield, this pacifier is sure to stay on your baby’s face comfortably.

This excellent pacifier is suitable for sensitive skins due to the fact that it has textured surface and several holes on the shield, which allow for efficient air circulation and thereby preventing the baby from choking issues. If you don’t fancy the glow in the dark feature of this pacifier, there are several other patterns and colors available that will be perfect for your little baby.


  • Glow-in-the-dark feature
  • Anti-slip texture
  • Orthodontic design
  • Ventilation holes for air circulation
  • Comes in varieties of colors


  • Some parents don’t like its glow-in-the-dark feature

7. Funny Baby Pacifier Cute Kissable Moustache

[amazon box=”B0771FWG15″ template=”vertical”]

We just couldn’t resist including this cute, funny pacifier. Apart from being one of the most popular options, which is hardly surprising considering its unique and funny design, the Babystache Funny Baby Pacifier is one of the best pacifiers on the market, and it is perfect for babies between the ages of 12 to 36 months.

Without any doubt, this cute pacifier is a very reliable option and it is one of the best in its class. We know you might be thinking its quirky look might mean it isn’t as good as other options, but that is totally untrue. Despite looking so strange, many parents rave about its incredible quality.

Furthermore, this pacifier is made with top quality silicone, which means it doesn’t have the strange odor and taste often found in most pacifiers. Also, it has an orthodontic design which helps with the development of the baby’s teeth and jaw. Besides, there are ventilation holes on its shield which consequently means better air circulation, making it perfect for sensitive skins.


  • Great air flow
  • Orthondox shape
  • Made with high-grade silicone
  • No strange odor or taste
  • Strong nipple


  • Has a quirky look

When Should I Introduce a Pacifier?

when to introduce a pacifier to baby

You shouldn’t introduce a pacifier to your baby immediately after birth. If a pacifier is introduced too soon, it may cause problems for your child. Because pacifiers and breastfeeding use dissimilar sucking motions, introducing your infant to a pacifier too early may cause him to have problems learning how to latch onto a real breast.

If you want to introduce a pacifier to your baby, you shouldn’t do it when the baby is anything less than one month, given your baby looks well-fed and looks to be doing great. In the event that your baby is having breastfeeding problems at one month old, don’t introduce the pacifier. If you at this point you give him a pacifier, your baby might end up being a lethargic sucker.

Things to Consider When Selecting Pacifiers

Pacifiers are not in any way the same. They vary in style, size, and nipple materials. Therefore, it is always important to check some factors before buying the right pacifier for your child. Below are the vital factors you will need to take into consideration. But keep in mind that it all comes down to the preference of your baby in the end.


Manufacturers usually offer three different sizes of pacifiers; for 3 months old babies. 3 – 9 months old babies, and 9 – 18 months old babies. Consider the age of your child and choose the size of the pacifier accordingly. Don’t give a toddler a pacifier meant for a newborn, and a choking issue may probably occur as a result of that. To follow safety protocols, the size of the pacifier ought to be 2.5 cm or even wider.

Nipple Material

The material of the nipple is another important consideration you must make. Usually, nipples are made of latex or silicon. Latex is probably the most accepted as they tend to be softer than silicon. However, some infants may be allergic to latex, you will therefore have to measure your options as regards the kind of material. Silicon is however the most popular option and it can be put in the dishwasher as well.


This isn’t us endorsing either type, but if you are using nipples made of latex, it is advisable to purchase more and often change them so as to prevent any breakdown. It is also advised to choose types that can be put in the dishwasher as it will guarantee their durability and sturdiness.

Ventilation Holes

Another important factor you must consider, make sure that the shield of the pacifier has holes for ventilation. A proper shield ought to have two holes at least on either side. These holes enable air circulation and ensure saliva accumulation is prevented as they can cause skin irritation.

Vivid Colors

Consider When Selecting Pacifiers

While this may seem like an unimportant consideration, it actually is important. Ensure you opt for a bright color when choosing. Your babies will find it easier when they can pacify themselves, and babies are usually attracted to bright colors. Also, the bright color may be useful at night when parents are unable to quickly find the pacifier.

Shield Size

The shield probably is the most essential part of any pacifier. A shield prevents your infant from fully putting the pacifier into his mouth. Therefore, you need to buy a pacifier that has a shield sufficiently big to stop your child from choking on the pacifier. This is vital as you want to ensure that the pacifier can’t enter their mouths. The guard should also have ventilation holes to prevent any sort of skin irritation that happens due to stuck moisture.

Here is the video about choosing the baby pacifiers.

How Many Pacifiers Do I Need?

Because of their small sizes, it is always extremely difficult to keep track of pacifiers. Therefore, you need to have more than one pacifier for your baby, particularly if your baby has started using them independently. If you have only have and it gets lost, you will have to live with an unhappy baby until it is replaced.

It is recommended to have 3 to 4 pacifiers at the very least. And if there is a particular style that your baby prefers, ensure you have several of that style. If he is accustomed to a certain type and it gets lost, your baby might be unhappy with the replacement you buy if they feel differently.

You will have to keep a pacifier or two in your bag and have extra two at home. Pacifiers aren’t expensive and it wouldn’t do you any harm to purchase extras. It is better to have too many than not having enough, right? We though as much as well.

How to Clean Pacifiers?

Except it is clearly stated on the packaging not to, most baby pacifiers can be cleaned the same way sippy cups and baby bottles are cleaned. You can also use the same sterilization process as sippy cups and baby bottles.

Consider When Selecting Pacifiers

After cleaning your baby’s pacifier, you may observe some remains of water or moisture in the nipple. It is absolutely normal. Just make sure you dry the pacifier as much as possible and ensure you get almost all the water out, and rest assure the remaining water will dry out eventually.

It can be advantageous to us several pacifiers as you the pacifiers can be easily swapped and you will get time to dry the ones you have washed. When you buy a brand new pacifier, ensure you wash and sanitize it before giving it you’re your child. Ensure you do this every time you get a new pacifier.

[Related: Best baby spoon]

Our Top Pick for Pacifiers

While there is an abundance of options when it comes to pacifiers for babies, choosing the right one is just very difficult, and it always comes down to the baby’s choice most times. However, if you can discover the right pacifier for your baby, it can help soothe a restless baby without you having to worry about orthodontic effects. Just ensure you take the important factors into consideration as we discussed above, and you are bound to end up with a fantastic pacifier.

Having reviewed some of the best baby pacifiers on the market in this article, we hope you will now be able to make a cognisant decision when choosing the right one. Although, all our choices are outstanding and promise to end your baby’s restlessness, but the one we deem as the most outstanding is the MAM Air Orthodontic Pacifier. Apart from its beautiful design, it is also designed to prevent your child from having any jaw-related issue. It has efficient ventilation holes, a large shield, and is also affordable. What more could a mom want? This pacifier from MAM is simply a must-have for all new moms.

Recommended Reading:

10 Best Sippy Cups for Breastfed Babies in 2018

10 Best Baby Bibs for Feeding & Keeping Baby Clean (2018)


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here